James Gunn hints that Brandon Sklenar could be in the running for DCU’s new Batman as fan buzz grows and the director praises his work in 1923.
Could the DC Universe have found its new Dark Knight? Over the past several weeks, Brandon Sklenar’s name has been dominating fan debates across comic book circles, with speculation that James Gunn may be eyeing him for one of the most important roles in his newly built DCU: Batman.
Sklenar, best known for his role as Spencer Dutton in Paramount+’s 1923 alongside Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren, has been the subject of intense fancasting as Bruce Wayne. Unlike many actors who stay silent on superhero chatter, Sklenar has openly admitted that playing Batman would be his ultimate dream role—putting him in the same lane as other hopefuls like Reacher star Alan Ritchson.
Gunn’s Comments Spark Buzz
The speculation gained traction after Gunn, on a Peacemaker podcast, casually mentioned that he was watching 1923. While praising the series, he called it “f—ing filthy” and singled out Sklenar’s performance, calling him “great.” Though Gunn also clarified that the Batman film isn’t officially in casting yet, his words immediately reignited rumors that Sklenar is firmly on his radar.
This isn’t without precedent. Gunn has a history of spotting actors he admires and later bringing them into his projects. He previously praised Milly Alcock’s performance in House of the Dragon, which eventually led to her auditioning—and landing—a role in the DCU. Fans also point to Aaron Pierre, who gained momentum from his Netflix film Rebel Ridge before being cast as Green Lantern’s John Stewart.
Fan Hype & Casting Debate
While Sklenar has his supporters, not everyone is convinced. His performance in the horror film Drop, co-starring Meghann Fahy of The White Lotus, showed range, but some argue that the excitement around him feels outsized. Batman is arguably the cornerstone of the DCU, and with Robert Pattinson’s version existing in a separate universe, the pressure to land the “right” Bruce Wayne is higher than ever.
For now, Gunn has emphasized that casting hasn’t begun, leaving Sklenar’s potential involvement as speculation. Still, the combination of fan demand, his vocal desire to don the cape and cowl, and Gunn’s public praise keeps the conversation alive.
Bottom Line
Nothing is official, but Brandon Sklenar may be closer to Gotham than some expect. If history repeats itself, Gunn’s admiration for an actor could be the first step toward a major casting. Whether Sklenar becomes the next Batman or not, the speculation underscores just how much weight this role carries in shaping the future of the DCU.
