Peter Weber Fires Back After Madison Prewett Says He Contacted Her 2 Days Before Moving On With Kelley Flanagan, Unfollows Her On Instagram!

Written by: Christine Akexis – April 22nd, 7:20pm pst


We know The Bachelor Presents: Listen To Your Heart is currently airing, but Peter Weber’s tumultuous love life continues to make headlines! The 28-year-old ABC star is pissed OFF and speaking OUT after Madison Prewett recently spilled some tea about his rumored relationship with Kelley Flanagan.

As reported, Madison went on Kaitlyn Bristowe’s Off the Vine podcast and said she was “thrown off” by her ex and former Bachelor BFF hanging out together lately. Kelley and Madison were super close during Peter’s season, so it was a huge shock to see those photos of the two quarantining together in Chicago! Madison got her revenge with a shady TikTok video featuring a few of Peter’s exes, but then she went on Kaitlyn’s podcast to call Peter out directly! Prewett claimed Weber sent her “I miss you” texts and spoke about wanting to work things out with her just TWO days before he met up with Flanagan.

(Credit: ABC)

The interview went viral and unsurprisingly, Peter took those words to heart! He hopped in the comments of a Bachelor Instagram fan account that was promoting Madison’s interview and said:

“@madiprew you’d think you’d have a little more respect for this situation given we both know there’s more to the story.”

WOW. A little more respect? Coming from the guy who’s rotating all of his exes? The former Bachelor really meant business considering he directly tagged her in the comment, too! These two definitely aren’t friendly exes anymore and fans also noticed he unfollowed her on IG around the same time.

YIKES!! What do you guys think Peter meant by there being “more to the story?” If so, why didn’t he just say it because we’re all DYING to know! Let us know your theories in the comments down below.

For AfterBuzz TV, I’m Christine Alexis and you can follow me on Twitter at @christineeebean. 

If you’re a fan of The Bachelor and the AfterBuzz TV Bachelor Aftershows, share this article with a friend.  Make sure you’re subscribed to all Afterbuzz channels so you never miss an update. See you next time!

About The Author:

Christine Alexis is a digital host for AfterBuzz TV and a staff writer for As a reality TV and pop culture expert, you’ll always find Christine scrolling her social media feeds for the latest scoop, a funny meme, or getting lost in a juicy Twitter thread.

More News

Euphoria special gets first date and more updates on the cast
We rank the episodes of season 2 of Unsolved Mysteries
Why you should be watching Youtube Originals new series Bravas
Cast gets ready for season 3 of In the Dark
What we predict to see in the new season of This is Us
It's down to the final three on Big Brother